The short answerYes. Across 982 answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews (21 October to 19 November 2026), adding a $5,000 or under-$10k monthly cap replaced 8 of the top 10 agencies named on no-budget prompts. Omniscient fell from 78.7% to 7.9%, Directive Consulting from 40.8% to 0.0%, and ChatGPT shifted 20.2% of citations to /pricing pages.
Measured 21 October to 19 November 2026 across 11 tracked B2B SaaS agency prompts (330 ChatGPT, 330 Perplexity and 322 Google AI Overviews answers) and 7,327 URL citations.
If you ask ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google AI Overviews for the best B2B SaaS SEO or AEO agency without naming a budget, the shortlist you get back assumes enterprise spend. Name a monthly ceiling ($5,000 a month or under $10,000 a month), and nearly every default leader disappears.
Ask about agency pricing without naming a dollar cap, though, and the enterprise defaults stay right where they are. That single difference separates buyers who see a realistic shortlist from buyers who burn two weeks on discovery calls with agencies priced above their ceiling.
| Agency | No-budget prompts (n=534) | Open pricing, no cap (n=270) | Monthly budget cap (n=178) | Shift (no-budget to cap) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Omniscient | 78.7% (420) | 44.4% (120) | 7.9% (14) | -70.8 pts |
| First Page Sage | 46.8% (250) | 18.5% (50) | 8.4% (15) | -38.4 pts |
| Siege Media | 44.8% (239) | 14.4% (39) | 4.5% (8) | -40.3 pts |
| iPullRank | 41.6% (222) | 21.1% (57) | 0.6% (1) | -41.0 pts |
| Directive Consulting | 40.8% (218) | 11.1% (30) | 0.0% (0) | -40.8 pts |
| Skale | 35.8% (191) | 11.5% (31) | 10.7% (19) | -25.1 pts |
| SimpleTiger | 30.5% (163) | 4.1% (11) | 14.0% (25) | -16.5 pts |
| Derivatex | 2.1% (11) | 13.3% (36) | 25.8% (46) | +23.7 pts |
| Optimist | 6.2% (33) | 10.0% (27) | 24.2% (43) | +18.0 pts |
| LoudFace | 7.9% (42) | 14.4% (39) | 19.1% (34) | +11.2 pts |
| TripleDart | 5.4% (29) | 2.6% (7) | 18.5% (33) | +13.1 pts |
| RevenueZen | 11.8% (63) | 5.9% (16) | 13.5% (24) | +1.7 pts |
| WebFX | 10.7% (57) | 2.2% (6) | 12.9% (23) | +2.2 pts |
| PipeRocket Digital | 1.3% (7) | 0.0% (0) | 12.4% (22) | +11.1 pts |
In October 2026, our funding-stage AI agency study grouped stage and budget questions together and left one practical question open: whether publishing prices where AI engines can read them actually changes who gets recommended. We ran a clean 30-day test across 982 answers and 7,327 URL citations to find out.
The answer splits sharply by engine. Adding a monthly budget cap drives a 112x jump in /pricing citation share on ChatGPT (from 0.18% to 20.24%, or 2 of 1,110 citations to 102 of 504), while Perplexity and Google AI Overviews barely touch /pricing pages at all.
How we ran the study
We pulled 30 complete UTC days of daily tracking data (21 October to 19 November 2026) from our Peec AI project across 11 US-English B2B SaaS agency prompts on three engines: ChatGPT (openai-0), Perplexity (perplexity-0) and Google AI Overviews (google-0).
Each prompt ran once per day per engine, producing 990 scheduled runs. Eight Google AI Overview runs returned no AI Overview block (six on no-budget prompts and two on budget-capped prompts), so every percentage below divides by actual answers returned: 982 answers in total (330 on ChatGPT, 330 on Perplexity and 322 on Google AI Overviews).
We split the 11 prompts into three cohorts so we could separate asking about pricing in general from stating a hard monthly ceiling:
- Monthly budget cap (2 prompts, 178 answers: ChatGPT 60, Perplexity 60, Google AI Overviews 58): "Is $5,000 a month reasonable for an SEO and AI search agency for a SaaS startup? Which agencies are in that range?" (89 answers) and "Which AEO agencies work on a monthly retainer under $10k?" (89 answers).
- Open pricing, no dollar cap (3 prompts, 270 answers: 90 per engine): "How much should a B2B SaaS expect to pay an AEO agency per month, and who is worth it at that price?" (90 answers), "How much does a B2B SaaS SEO retainer cost per month" (90 answers) and "Compare the top AI search agencies for B2B SaaS on pricing, specialization and proof." (90 answers).
- No-budget baseline (6 prompts, 534 answers: ChatGPT 180, Perplexity 180, Google AI Overviews 174): "Best AEO agencies 2026" (89), "Best GEO agencies" (89), "Best AEO agency for B2B SaaS 2026" (90), "Best agency for AI search optimization for SaaS" (89), "Best SEO agency for B2B SaaS companies" (87) and "Top B2B SaaS SEO agencies in 2026" (90).
One boundary matters when reading the brand counts: Peec's brand visibility report tracks the 55 brands configured in our project (mostly SEO and AI search agencies, plus a few non-agency brands such as independent consultant Nathan Ojaokomo; 44 of the 55 were named at least once across these 11 prompts). Agencies outside those 55 (for example Kern Media or Arobis AI, both of whose /pricing pages ChatGPT cited) appear in our URL citation totals but do not appear in the 55-brand mention counts. Read every agency percentage as the share of answers naming that tracked brand rather than a closed universe of every agency worldwide.
For the URL citation audit (7,327 citations across all 982 answers), we classified every cited URL by two simple rules: whether the URL path or page title carried pricing intent (matching price, pricing, cost, retainer, budget, rate, under-10k, under-5k, 5k or 5000) and whether the URL path ended in /pricing (a subset of pricing-topic URLs). On ChatGPT (102 of 102 budget-cap /pricing citations) and Perplexity (5 of 5), every counted /pricing URL belonged to an agency. On Google AI Overviews, path matching also caught three directory /pricing citations: two to DesignRush on open-pricing prompts and one to G2 (g2.com/products/tripledart/pricing) on budget-cap prompts, leaving 15 of 16 budget-cap /pricing citations agency-owned (3.0% of AIO budget-cap citations).
Why do enterprise SEO leaders vanish when you name a dollar cap?
Only 2 of the top 10 agencies on no-budget prompts (Skale and SimpleTiger) stay in the top 10 once a buyer adds a $5,000 or under-$10k monthly cap. The other 8 drop out completely.
Look at the top five no-budget leaders across all three engines:
| Agency | ChatGPT: no-budget vs cap | Perplexity: no-budget vs cap | Google AI Overviews: no-budget vs cap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Omniscient | 98.9% (178/180) vs 5.0% (3/60) | 75.6% (136/180) vs 10.0% (6/60) | 60.9% (106/174) vs 8.6% (5/58) |
| First Page Sage | 63.9% (115/180) vs 11.7% (7/60) | 31.7% (57/180) vs 3.3% (2/60) | 44.8% (78/174) vs 10.3% (6/58) |
| Siege Media | 62.2% (112/180) vs 3.3% (2/60) | 38.9% (70/180) vs 1.7% (1/60) | 32.8% (57/174) vs 8.6% (5/58) |
| iPullRank | 63.3% (114/180) vs 0.0% (0/60) | 32.8% (59/180) vs 0.0% (0/60) | 28.2% (49/174) vs 1.7% (1/58) |
| Directive Consulting | 55.0% (99/180) vs 0.0% (0/60) | 32.2% (58/180) vs 0.0% (0/60) | 35.1% (61/174) vs 0.0% (0/58) |
The magnitude of that drop is rare in AI search data. On ChatGPT, Omniscient appears in 178 of 180 no-budget answers (98.9%). Add a monthly budget ceiling and ChatGPT names it in 3 of 60 answers (5.0%), a 93.9-percentage-point collapse. iPullRank goes from 63.3% on ChatGPT and 32.8% on Perplexity to 0.0% on both. Directive Consulting hits 0.0% across all 178 budget-capped answers on all three engines.
Animalz and NoGood follow the same curve: neither appears in a single budget-capped answer on ChatGPT or Perplexity, leaving Animalz at 1.7% overall (3/178, down from 20.8% or 111/534 on no-budget prompts) and NoGood at 1.1% (2/178, down from 20.6% or 110/534).
That matters because buyers rarely click through to audit AI summaries themselves. A July 2025 Pew Research Center study of 900 U.S. adults across 68,879 Google searches found that users who saw an AI summary clicked a traditional search result in 8% of visits (compared with 15% without one), clicked a link inside the AI summary in just 1% of visits, and ended their session on 26% of pages versus 16% without a summary. Whoever sits inside that first AI shortlist gets the intro call.
Omniscient named rate across 534 no-budget answers vs 178 monthly budget-cap answers (LoudFace Peec AI study, 21 October to 19 November 2026).
Open pricing questions do not filter out enterprise agencies
Asking an AI engine about pricing without naming your monthly cap does not produce a mid-market or startup shortlist. Across the 270 open-pricing answers, 6 of the top 10 no-budget leaders (Omniscient, First Page Sage, Siege Media, iPullRank, Directive Consulting and Skale) stay in the top 10.
Omniscient still leads the open-pricing cohort at 44.4% (120/270: 64.4% on ChatGPT, 31.1% on Perplexity and 37.8% on Google AI Overviews). iPullRank sits second at 21.1% (57/270), followed by First Page Sage and Discovered Labs tied at 18.5% (50/270 each), then Siege Media and LoudFace tied at 14.4% (39/270 each).
Zoom into the three open-pricing prompts and the split becomes even clearer:
| Open-pricing prompt (n=90 each) | ChatGPT top named | Perplexity top named | Google AI Overviews top named |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compare top AI search agencies on pricing, specialization and proof | Omniscient (100.0%), iPullRank (86.7%), Discovered Labs (63.3%) | Omniscient (76.7%), Derivatex (73.3%), LoudFace (56.7%) | Omniscient (66.7%), Directive Consulting (60.0%), First Page Sage and Siege Media (36.7% each) |
| How much should B2B SaaS pay an AEO agency per month, and who is worth it? | Omniscient (83.3%), First Page Sage (46.7%), iPullRank (36.7%) | Omniscient (16.7%), Derivatex (13.3%), Grow and Convert, LoudFace and Optimist (6.7% each) | First Page Sage (46.7%), Discovered Labs and Omniscient (43.3% each) |
| How much does a B2B SaaS SEO retainer cost per month | Powered by Search (40.0%), Grow and Convert (36.7%), MADX Digital (36.7%) | None of the 55 tracked brands named (0.0%) | Discovered Labs (16.7%), First Page Sage (10.0%), Omniscient, RevenueZen and TripleDart (3.3% each) |
Look at that bottom row. When a buyer asks purely about monthly retainer cost without asking who to hire, Perplexity named zero of the 55 tracked brands across 30 daily runs, and Google AI Overviews named only five at low rates (led by Discovered Labs at 16.7%). ChatGPT still named Powered by Search (40.0%), Grow and Convert (36.7%) and MADX Digital (36.7%) while giving zero citations to any of their own sites on this prompt. Instead, it cited third-party pricing guides led by therankmaster.com/insights/b2b-saas-seo-agency-pricing (36 citations), ayrank.com/blog/saas-seo-cost-2026 (25 citations) and nathanojaokomo.com/blog/seo-agency-pricing (19 citations), with both the therankmaster.com and nathanojaokomo.com guides listing all three agencies.
The moment the prompt adds "compare on pricing" or "who is worth it at that price" with no ceiling, ChatGPT puts Omniscient in 100.0% and 83.3% of answers. If your budget is $5,000 to $10,000 a month, asking "compare AI search agencies on pricing" hands you almost the exact same enterprise roster as asking with no budget context at all.
ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews pick three different winners under a budget cap
Our October cross-engine study across 500 answer sets found that 71% of agencies AI recommends appear on only one engine. Adding a monthly budget cap pushes that disagreement even further: across all 178 budget-capped answers, zero agencies appear in the top five on all three engines.
| Engine position | ChatGPT (n=60) | Perplexity (n=60) | Google AI Overviews (n=58) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Derivatex (50.0%, 30) | Optimist (41.7%, 25) | Breaking B2B (22.4%, 13) |
| 2 | PipeRocket Digital (36.7%, 22) | LoudFace (23.3%, 14) | SimpleTiger (17.2%, 10) |
| 3 | TripleDart (35.0%, 21) | Skale (20.0%, 12) | Percepture (15.5%, 9) and LoudFace (15.5%, 9) |
| 4 | RevenueZen (26.7%, 16) | Derivatex (18.3%, 11) | (tied for 3rd above) |
| 5 | WebFX (25.0%, 15) | Discovered Labs (16.7%, 10) and Minuttia (16.7%, 10) | WebFX, Optimist and Discovered Labs (12.1%, 7 each) |
PipeRocket Digital is the starkest single-engine spike in the dataset: named in 36.7% of ChatGPT budget-cap answers (22 of 60), and 0 of 60 on Perplexity, 0 of 58 on Google AI Overviews. Discovered Labs runs in the opposite direction: 0 of 60 on ChatGPT, 16.7% on Perplexity and 12.1% on Google AI Overviews. Percepture also sits at 0 of 60 on ChatGPT while hitting 15.0% on Perplexity and 15.5% on Google AI Overviews.
If you run your budget-capped vendor search in only one AI tool, you are reading one engine's retrieval bias rather than the market. That matches what our industry study found on 1,548 answers in November 2026: engines split sharply once a buyer narrows the prompt.
Even $5,000 a month vs under $10k a month splits the shortlist
We expected the two monthly-cap prompts ($5,000 a month and under $10,000 a month) to return overlapping mid-market lists, yet they shared only one agency in the top six.
| Prompt (n=89 each) | Top 6 agencies named (3-engine share) | ChatGPT leader | Perplexity leader | Google AI Overviews leader |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $5,000/mo for a SaaS startup | Derivatex (41.6%), TripleDart (27.0%), SimpleTiger (27.0%), Breaking B2B (20.2%), Skale (20.2%), LoudFace (16.9%) | Derivatex (90.0%, 27/30) | Skale (40.0%, 12/30) | Breaking B2B (44.8%, 13/29) |
| AEO agencies under $10k/mo | Optimist (44.9%), WebFX (22.5%), RevenueZen (21.3%), LoudFace (21.3%), Discovered Labs (18.0%), Revv Growth (18.0%) | WebFX and RevenueZen (43.3%, 13/30 each) | Optimist (73.3%, 22/30) | Optimist and Discovered Labs (24.1%, 7/29 each) |
LoudFace is the only tracked agency in the top six of both prompts: sixth on the $5,000/month startup question (16.9%: ChatGPT 10.0%, Perplexity 23.3%, Google AI Overviews 17.2%) and tied for third on the under-$10k/month AEO question (21.3%: ChatGPT 26.7%, Perplexity 23.3%, Google AI Overviews 13.8%).
Notice why the two caps diverge so cleanly. The $5,000 prompt says "SEO and AI search agency for a SaaS startup", which pulls SaaS SEO agencies whose pricing pages or guides mention starter retainers around $5,000 a month (Derivatex at 90.0% on ChatGPT, TripleDart at 70.0% on ChatGPT, SimpleTiger at 43.3% on ChatGPT and 31.0% on AI Overviews). The under-$10k prompt says "AEO agencies", which pulls dedicated AEO pricing guides where Optimist leads Perplexity at 73.3% (22 of 30 runs) and WebFX and RevenueZen lead ChatGPT at 43.3% each.
Two words ("startup" plus "$5,000" versus "AEO" plus "under $10k") change five of the top six names.
Why it happens: ChatGPT reads /pricing pages, while Perplexity and AI Overviews read pricing guides
To test the hypothesis our October funding-stage paper left untested ("put your price where an engine can read it"), we audited all 7,327 URL citations across the 982 answers. The retrieval shift is unmistakable, and it works completely differently on ChatGPT than on Perplexity or Google AI Overviews.
| Prompt group | Engine | Total citations | Pricing-topic URLs (% of cites) | Direct /pricing pages (% of cites) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No-budget baseline | ChatGPT | 1,110 | 5.6% (62) | 0.2% (2) |
| No-budget baseline | Perplexity | 983 | 6.7% (66) | 0.0% (0) |
| No-budget baseline | Google AI Overviews | 1,670 | 4.7% (79) | 0.0% (0) |
| Open pricing, no cap | ChatGPT | 807 | 37.2% (300) | 2.7% (22) |
| Open pricing, no cap | Perplexity | 594 | 46.8% (278) | 1.5% (9) |
| Open pricing, no cap | Google AI Overviews | 778 | 66.5% (517) | 1.3% (10) |
| Monthly budget cap | ChatGPT | 504 | 48.8% (246) | 20.2% (102) |
| Monthly budget cap | Perplexity | 385 | 63.9% (246) | 1.3% (5) |
| Monthly budget cap | Google AI Overviews | 496 | 72.2% (358) | 3.2% (16) |
Across all three engines combined, pricing-topic URLs jump from 5.5% of citations on no-budget prompts (207 of 3,763) to 61.4% on budget-cap prompts (850 of 1,385). That part matches how modern retrieval works: Google Search Central documents that AI Overviews and AI Mode use query fan-out, "issuing multiple related searches across subtopics and data sources", and Google's AI Mode announcement describes the system "breaking down your question into subtopics and issuing a multitude of queries simultaneously on your behalf."
We see that exact fan-out rewrite in ChatGPT's live Peec transcripts from 12 November 2026. On the $5,000/month prompt, ChatGPT issued searches like:
SEO agency monthly retainers $5000 SaaS startup AI search optimization agency pricing 2026SaaS SEO agencies pricing monthly retainer $3000 $7000 AI search optimization GEO agenciessite:tripledart.com pricing SEO GEO $5000 monthly SaaS agency
On the under-$10k prompt, ChatGPT searched AEO agencies answer engine optimization monthly retainer pricing under $10,000 per month 2026. That explains our fan-out queries finding in action: the dollar ceiling rewrites the background search before the engine ever looks for agencies.
Then the three engines diverge sharply on what they trust:
- ChatGPT goes straight to agency
/pricingpages. Under budget caps, direct/pricingURLs jump 112x in raw citation share on ChatGPT, from 0.18% (2 of 1,110, rounded to 0.2% in the table) on no-budget prompts to 20.24% (102 of 504, rounded to 20.2%) on budget-cap prompts, and all 102 were agency-owned. ChatGPT's most-cited/pricingpages werederivatex.agency/pricing(35 ChatGPT citations across 26 retrievals),kernmedia.com/pricing(20 citations),arobis.ai/pricing(9 citations),madx.digital/pricing(5 citations) and009.agency/pricing(5 citations). - Perplexity leans on non-
/pricingpricing pages over direct/pricingURLs. Direct/pricingpages made up just 1.3% of Perplexity's budget-cap citations (5 of 385, all agency-owned). Excluding those 5/pricingcitations, other pricing-topic pages accounted for 62.6% (241 of 385), led by pricing listicles, comparisons, articles and guides (204 citations across both third-party sites and agency blogs, plus 37 other pricing and service pages). - Google AI Overviews pulls the highest share of non-
/pricingpricing content. Excluding direct/pricingURLs (3.2%, or 16 of 496; 15 agency-owned plus 1 G2 directory/pricingpage), other pricing-topic pages made up 69.0% of AI Overviews budget-cap citations (342 of 496). Listicles, comparisons, articles and guides accounted for 249 of those 342 citations across third-party publishers and agency blogs, alongside service, forum, directory and other pricing pages.
Each engine trusts a different corpus, and budget prompts make that split unmistakable.
Here is the blunt proof from our own site. LoudFace publishes its starting price on our plans and pricing page ("Engagements start from $5k / mo" across Solo, Dual and Scale Autopilot tiers). Across all 178 budget-cap answers, loudface.co/pricing was retrieved once (on Perplexity) and cited zero times. Meanwhile, our comparative study of 25 AI search agencies that publish pricing (which spans $590 a month to $50,000+ a month, with 9 of 25 floors between $3,000 and $3,500) was retrieved 44 times and cited 28 times across all three engines.
Publishing a /pricing page is not enough on its own. Our own site proved that in black and white. If your /pricing page lacks clear query-matching copy pairing your monthly dollar band with your exact service category (SEO, AEO and GEO for B2B SaaS), ChatGPT skips it in favor of /pricing pages that state the dollar number right next to the service label. And even a strong /pricing page barely moves Perplexity (1.3% /pricing share) or Google AI Overviews (3.2% /pricing share), because both engines pull their budget shortlists from pricing guides, comparisons and agency roundups where brands must be named on retrieved pages.
Direct /pricing page citation share by prompt type and engine across 7,327 citations (LoudFace Peec AI study, 21 October to 19 November 2026).
What this changes if you are hiring an agency in 2026
If you are a Series A to C founder or CMO using ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google to shortlist an SEO or AI search partner, stop running plain category prompts. Plain prompts return the agencies with the biggest third-party listicle footprint instead of the agencies built for your monthly budget.
- Put your actual monthly number in the prompt. Do not ask "compare agencies on pricing" or "what is a fair price and who is worth it." As our 270 open-pricing answers showed, those prompts still put Omniscient first at 44.4% and keep 6 of the top 10 enterprise incumbents in place. Write the ceiling explicitly ("$5,000 a month or under $10,000 a month for a B2B SaaS").
- Run the same budget prompt on at least two engines. Zero agencies sat in the top five across ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews under a budget cap. ChatGPT surfaces agencies with explicit
/pricingpages; Perplexity and Google AI Overviews surface agencies featured in pricing guides. Checking only one gives you half the market. - Verify every quoted price on the agency's own site. AI answers routinely pull outdated dollar bands from third-party pricing blogs, or surface agencies like First Page Sage (still named in 8.4% of budget-cap answers) and Omniscient (7.9%) even when you asked for under $10,000 a month. Use our breakdown of AEO agency pricing for B2B SaaS alongside each vendor's live pricing page before you book calls.
What this changes if you are a B2B SaaS company trying to win budget-scoped AI answers
The same mechanics apply far outside marketing agencies. Any B2B software category where buyers search with a budget ceiling ("under $500 a month", "for a 20-person team", "startup pricing") splits along the same fault line between ChatGPT and Google or Perplexity.
- For ChatGPT, make your
/pricingpage match buyer fan-out queries. State your entry price, billing unit, target company stage and core category phrase in plain server-rendered HTML instead of hiding them behind a calculator widget or "Contact sales." ChatGPT literally runssite:<domain> pricing <category> <dollar amount>searches when a buyer names a number. - For Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, win the pricing guides they already cite. Because direct
/pricingpages account for only 1.3% of Perplexity citations and 3.2% of Google AI Overviews citations under budget caps, your/pricingpage will not carry those two engines by itself. Audit which pricing roundups and benchmark posts appear in your category's budget prompts, then earn accurate placement in those third-party guides and publish a structured pricing comparison on your own blog. - Measure named rate per engine, never blended. A blended score hides an agency or SaaS brand that hits 36.7% on ChatGPT while sitting at 0.0% on Perplexity and Google AI Overviews (exactly what PipeRocket Digital experienced in our dataset). Our SEO and AEO service and GEO agency program track visibility engine by engine against live buyer prompts.
Want to see which competitors ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity name when buyers ask about your category at your price point? Run our free AI visibility audit to get an AI search presence score, a side-by-side comparison against your top three competitors, one fix you can ship within a week and a personal Loom from Arnel.
Every company that hides its pricing behind a demo form is handing budget-qualified AI buyers straight to competitors who publish a clear dollar floor. On ChatGPT alone, /pricing pages went from 0.2% of citations to 20.2% the moment a buyer typed a monthly budget, and the agencies that refused to state a price vanished from the shortlist.

